Events - Past seminars
Health Economics Seminar - "Consistency in performance evaluation reports and medical records" by Dr Lu Mingshan & Prof Albert Ma
backuphomesearch

Date: March 14, 2002
Time: 11:00 - 12:15
Venue: G05 Patrick Manson Building (South Wing), 7 Sassoon Road, Pokfulam, HKU

Microeconomics has long been used to explain physicians' behaviour. Health care delivery and financing nowadays have become very elaborate. Increasingly, clinicians are asked to report on patients before referrals are approved, treatments authorized, or insurance claims processed. Although these myriad of procedures may have been installed for cost containment or quality enhancement purposes, clinicians often find them interfering with care delivery while patients regard them as rationing mechanisms. As reactions, clinicians sometimes have to make strategic decisions about what to report and omit to insurer and payers. The existing health literature has already pointed out that gaming, sincere reporting, nudging, and dodging the rules by providers are important (Morreim HE, 1991. Archives of Internal Medicine. 151:443-447).

In this study, the authors report a unique data set for studying gaming; our focus is on alcohol treatment programs in the state of Maine, USA. They compare two reports made by a clinician on a patient. One report is used by the Maine Office of Substance Abuse (OSA) to evaluate provider performance; the second is an actual clinical record. This is perhaps the first study in which two reports made by the same clinician are examined directly. This allows us to assess directly the extent of gaming. The motives of physician's mis-reporting, i.e. financial motive and altruistic
motive are explained.

Download seminar material